“There are so many babies that need to be adopted in South Africa.” Is this true? And if so why is there not a lot of adoptions taking place in our country?
In South Africa reference is often made to how hard it is to adopt, or to the 1000’s of children needing care or families. There is no doubt that children found in need of care is a serious social challenge in our country. However, as Arise we believe that it is vital to know and understand the full context before decisions and conclusions are made. So then where does one start to wade through the facts and myths that permeate conversations in different spaces?
We’ve put together the 7 common myths or assumptions about adoption in South African that come to us either through workshops or conferences; and provided the facts for you. Hopefully this will help as you navigate adoption related conversations.
- Myth: There are thousands of children without parents needing to be adopted.
Fact: South Africa has a population of about 20 million children under the age of 18. 400 000 of these children are identified as being in alternative care – whether foster care or Child and Youth Care centres. However this does not mean that they are adoptable. Many are in the system and will return to their families when it is safe to do so. Statistics suggest that on average 1 400 adoptions are processed a year and of these, two thirds are kinship or familial adoptions – where the child remains in their biological family. This means we need to recognise that families are in crisis and need help, not that there are thousands of babies in need of permanency.
2. Myth: It is possible to adopt a newborn baby in South Africa.
Fact: Newborn babies, in terms of South African law, are not adoptable until their biological family have been given the opportunity to change their minds within the 60- or 90-day period. While the trauma of being separated from their biological family and placed is care is very real, so too is the ethical challenge to ensure that children and prospective adoptive parents are protected. During the period that a biological family has to confirm that they are relinquishing any right to parenting, it is best practice to ensure no undue pressure is put on the biological family and they are free to change their minds. This is the reason for temporary safe care placements between relinquishment and adoption.
3. Myth: All biological mothers who make an adoption plan do so because they can’t parent their baby/child and if adequate support was given, they would parent their child.
Fact: Many biological mothers choose adoption for various reasons, such as financial instability, lack of support, or personal circumstances. Providing adequate support can often help them in parenting their child, but a lack of resources or support is not always the sole reason for choosing adoption. Some mothers or families will cite the need to know that they can care in the long term for a child while others are making a conscious choice that they do not want to be a parent at this point in their lives.
4. Myth: Adoptions are closed in South Africa and the law doesn’t make allowances for any form of contact until the child is 18.
Fact: In South Africa, open adoptions are allowed as long as there is mutual consent from the biological family, adoptive family, and professionals who determine that it is in the best interests of the child. This means that there is no known risk of danger – physical or emotional to the child and that the biological family, adoptee and adoptive family have clear and honest expectations. Open adoptions can provide ongoing communication, without necessarily being about contact between the birth parents and the adoptive family, allowing for a more transparent and connected relationship for the benefit of the child. This also allows the child to have a connection with their heritage and roots.
5. Myth: The younger a child is when adopted, the less likely there is to be behavioural challenges when they are older.
Fact: While early adoption can have benefits in terms of attachment and bonding, it does not guarantee the absence of behavioural challenges in the future. Things such as exposure to trauma, drugs, alcohol and genetics will influence a child’s developmental trajectory. Regardless of the age at which a child is adopted, there will be tasks that adoptive parents need to be mindful of to support their children as they mature and develop through life.
6. Myth: Culture doesn’t matter. Once a child is yours, you shape everything about that child:
Fact: While adoptive parents play a crucial role in shaping a child’s upbringing and environment, it’s important to acknowledge the child’s constitutional right to their roots and heritage. Culture in the South African context is often linked to racial identity too and while we might wish that the world wasn’t race conscious or that race doesn’t matter, we are reminded daily that it does. Additionally, developing a positive racial identity requires conscious intent and deliberate action on the part of the adoptive parents.
7. Myth: Children only need to be told their story when they ask.
Fact: Children need their parents to give permission to ask for more information about their story without feeling conflicted about doing so. This requires that adoptive parents understand that they are custodians of their child’s origin and birth story. Helping children understand their full story before they enter the teens is critical to supporting their development.
These are only a few of the statements made in wider adoption spaces. There are many more. As Arise, we believe that every child belongs in a thriving family and should be afforded the opportunity to reach their full potential. It is why we acknowledge the need to look at family preservation as well as family strengthening, regardless of how families are formed.
If you have more questions or want to dig deeper into what adoption in South Africa is about, consider accessing our free webinar on Trauma in Adoption as well as exploring other adoption related self-paced courses such as Looking In (a great starting point!).